A Sad and Tragic Mess

I picked up a free paper on the way home from work last night. The headlines screamed that a child in Halstead, Essex had been savaged to death by a dog. The report described how a neighbour had seen a white dog sitting quietly, its face covered in blood moments after a child’s wild and distressed cries had startled the neighbourhood. The report went on to mention the number of attacks by dogs reported in recent weeks. The underlying message, intentional or otherwise, was that dogs were dangerous. There were also hints that it might have been a breed on the banned dogs list. A list that has been shown over and over again to be nonsense.

Later I watched the news on the television. The same story was covered. The attack sounded horrific, the stuff of nightmares. I was wondering how this could have occurred, then the camera panned back to show a windowless shed, the place the dog had been kept.

Now don’t get me wrong. A child attacked by a dog is not something I take lightly, and this child was killed. It couldn’t be worse. But if someone acquires a dog and then keeps it shut in a shed, it is not likely to acquire the skills that will make it a happy socialised animal. Something is likely to go badly wrong.

I watch the animal rescue programmes. The cruelty of some pet owners is almost beyond belief. When prosecuted they get banned from keeping animals for a few years; five or ten usually it seems. It is extremely rare for someone to be banned for life. Maybe they also have to attend some sort of course that teaches them empathy with other living creatures; I don’t know.

I imagine the dog in the incident in Halstead has by now been killed. The owner was arrested for allowing a dog to be dangerously out of control and injuring a person. I don’t know the whole story, and maybe it was a freakish dog with a very aggressive temperament. But I’ll be surprised if it turns out that way.

Human beings make dangerous dogs by not looking after them properly. And when those dogs attack, it is they who are destroyed. Though you could argue, and I would, that have already been destroyed by people who should never have a dog in the first place. My fear with stories like these is that we as a society demonise dogs, and increasingly exclude them from public areas, thus decreasing their chances of being well socialised and increasing the chances of neurotic and aggressive behaviour. Health and safety is often used as an excuse to ban dogs from places where they used to be free to accompany their owners, despite the fact that the regulations do not require such a ban.

It is more than time to reassess our relationships with our fellow animals.


8 thoughts on “A Sad and Tragic Mess

    • One of the things that convinced me that the Netherlands is a civilised country was seeing dogs accompanying their owners into shops, cafés and other public spaces as a norm. In 2012, staying in Alkmaar, I did not see one nervous or over boisterous dog. They were not left shut up at home because their owners tasks led them to places where dogs were not allowed. The result was a population of socialised, well-balanced dogs.

  1. Rehoming centres are full of reasons why some people shouldn’t be allowed to own animals. I know your own experience of trying to rehome was full of prejudice, but I think there should be some kind of licensing for animal ownership with a fee that would pay for wardens to properly monitor it – perhaps based on vet references or pre and post adoption home visits.

    • I agree. Too many people buy pets on a whim, sometimes even as an accessory. Breeders who want to make a living from selling animals of any sort need to be regulated. I read a horrifying story of a family on low income who let their dog have several litters of puppies to pay for a new kitchen. While money is the driving force behind many people breeding from animals ethical behaviour is likely to come a very poor second. I believe CPL, Dogs Trust, Battersea and the RSPCA do further visits after an animal has been rehomed through them to make sure all is well. Vet references would have allowed me to rehome a cat through Celia Hammond. It’s something I suggested to them, but they didn’t want to know. 😦

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.